Left and the Falklands – Malvinas war
The work devoted to the intellectual discussions that took place in Argentina in the context of the Falklands / Malvinas war of the 1982. The article argues that while the left parties supported the war, a minority of intellectuals on the left Ted Grant, Adolfo Gilli, Alan Woods, Alberto Bonnet and some other opposed it. According to the left parties the war between Argentina and the United Kingdom over the Falklands – Malvinas islands contained a progressive content on Argentina side. The attack on the Falklands – Malvinas islands was directed against British imperialism. The left parties presented the war as ending “one of the last refuges of colonialism” in Latin America. They argued that since Argentina was a semi-colonial country it should be supported in the war. Marxists have always given support to national struggle against imperialism. The struggle for national liberation. The intellectuals on the left censured the war. The war was reactionary on both sides. Their attitude to war between Britain and Argentina was determined by which class is wage the war. On both sides it was capitalist powers which were involved and therefore they were opposed the war on both Britain and Argentina. Argentina was not a poor exploited colony although there are some semi-colonial features, particularly dependence on foreign capital. It is, of course in no position to play an imperialist role on the world scale like USA and Great Britain, but the Argentina bourgeoisie had imperialist ambitions within South America. The claim of the Argentinean bourgeoisie to possession of the Falkland – Malvinas on the ground of self-determination had no basis. If there had been a population on the islands composed of argentines, opposed by the British and fighting to unite with Argentina. In that case the Marxists would be duty bound to support them in their struggle against British imperialism but there was not a single Argentine living there. All of them English speaking. The conquest of the Falkland – Malvinas by the Argentine army was not an act of liberation but an act of violence against them. By invading the Falklands – Malvinas in 1982 the Argentina junta armed to disorient and deceive the masses at home.
References
Брутенц К.Н. Конфликт в Южной Атлантике: некоторые последствия и уроки // США: экономика, политика, идеология. 1982. № 10. Brutents K.N. Konflikt v Yuzhnoi Atlantike: nekotorye posledstviya i uroki // SShA: ekonomika, politika, ideologiya. 1982. № 10. [Conflict in the South Atlantic: some implications and lessons learned]
Грабивкер М.К. Империалистические корни кризиса // Проблемы мир и социализма. 1982. № 7. Grabivker M.K. Imperialisticheskie korni krizisa // Problemy mira i sotsializma. 1982. № 7. [The imperialist roots of the crisis]
Дмитриев В. Кризис колониалистской политики империализма в Латинской Америке // Международная жизнь. 1982. №9. Dmitriev V. Krizis kolonialistskoi politiki v Latinskoi Amerike // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn’. 1982. №9. [The Crisis of Imperialism's Colonialist Policies in Latin America]
Лунин В.Н. Кризис в Южной Атлантике и его последствия // Латинская Америка. 1982. № 11. Lunin V.N. Krizic v YuzhnoiAtlantike i ego posledstviya // Latinskaya Amerika. 1982. №11. [The crisis in the South Atlantic and its aftermath]
Мальвины: колониальная война ХХ века. М. ИЛА, 1984. [Malviny: kolonialnaya voina XX veka. [Malvinas: the colonial warfare of the twentieth century]
Поллок Дж. Безумие военных авантюр // Проблемы мира и социализма. 1982. № 7. Pollok Dzh. Bezymie voennykh avantyur // Problemy mira i sotsializma. 1982. № 7. [The folly of military adventures]
Фава А. После Мальвинского кризиса все стало иначе // Проблемы мира и социализма. 1983. №4. Fava A. Posle Malvinskogo krisisa vse stalo inache // Problemy mira i sotsializma. 1983. № 4. [Things have been different since the Malvinas crisis]
Щелчков А.А. Союзники поневоле: СССР, компартия Аргентины перед лицом военной диктатуры (1976–1983) // Новая и новейшая история. 2024. №4. Schelchkov A.A. Soyuzniki ponevole: SSSR, kompartiya Argentiny pered litsom voennoidiktatury (1976–1983) // Novaya i noveishaya istoriya. 2024. № 4. [Allies of Willing Allies: USSR, Communist Party of Argentina in the Face of Military Dictatorship (1976-1983)]
Arevalo O. El partido comunista у la Argentina. Buenos Aires: Centro Editor de America Latina. 1983.
Coggiola O. El trotskismo argentine. 1960–1982. Buenos Aires, 1986.
La izquierda y la guerra de Malvina / Adolfo Gilly; Alan Woods; Alberto Bonnet. Buenos Aires: RyR, 2012.
Mercader S. Lógica militarista y nacionalista versus subjetividad antinacionalista. Los debates intelectuales en torno a la Guerra de Malvinas en la revista Punto de Vista // Humanidades. Revista de la Universidad de Montevideo, n 9. 2021.
Novarro M. Historia de la Argentina. 1955–2010. Buenos Aires: El siglo veintiuno, 2010.
Novarro A., Paermo V. La dictadura military 1976–1983: del golpe de estado a la restauración democratica. Buenos Aires: Paidos, 2011.
Pendosa T. La internacional socialista y la guerra de Malvinas // Latin American Research Review. Vol. 49. N 2, 2014.